Summary
Shelia Y. Oliver Academy is a PK–8 school in East Orange serving 413 students, in the East Orange School District, which ranks at the 12th percentile and has a 1-star SchoolDigger rating. The school’s own 2025–2026 SchoolDigger ranking is higher, at 878 of 1,331 New Jersey schools, the 34th percentile and 2 stars. The clearest takeaway is that results are stronger than the district’s in ELA, math and science, but remain below state averages in all three.
ELA is the school’s strongest subject against the state, while science is its weakest: 2025–2026 averages were 45% in ELA, 32% in math and 14% in science, respectively 6, 8 and 9 percentage points below state averages. Oliver was above the district in all three, by 15 points in ELA, 14 in math and 7 in science. Some grade-level results stand out locally: seventh-grade ELA was 61%, the highest among nearby schools reporting that grade, and fifth-grade science at 23% led nearby schools reporting results. Eighth-grade math was 32%, ahead of reported results at First Avenue School and Salome Urena Elementary School. Sixth grade is a concern: ELA was 25%, versus 51% statewide, and math was 17%, versus 40% statewide.
Longer-term averages have improved, though the latest ELA results are uneven. From 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, ELA rose from 33% to 45%, math from 19% to 32%, and science from 4% to 14%; SchoolDigger’s overall percentile increased from 19 to 34. But ELA fell from 53% in 2024–2025 to 45% the next year, including a sixth-grade drop from 75% to 25%. Oliver’s student-teacher ratio was 13.7 in 2024–2025, around the middle of nearby schools, and 15% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible that year. SchoolDigger’s effectiveness ranking for African American students was at the 76th percentile in 2025–2026, compared with 34 overall; its ranking for Hispanic students fell from the 52nd to the 26th percentile in one year.
Thank you for your feedback!