Summary:
The six elementary schools in Garfield Public School District all serve PK–5 and enroll 2,122 students combined, with school enrollments ranging from 280 to 441. In 2025–26, the six-school averages were 45% in ELA, 34% in math and 24% in fifth-grade science, each below the state’s grade-matched average of 49%, 47% and 27%, respectively. The most important concern is the sharp area-wide weakness in math: the average was 13 points below the state.
Thomas Jefferson School #9 led in overall ELA at 57%, 10 points above next-highest Roosevelt School #7 at 47%, and had the highest math average at 44%. James Madison School #10 stood out in science at 44%, compared with 26% at the next-highest school, Washington Irving School #4. At the lower end, Abraham Lincoln School #6 had the lowest ELA average, 31%, and science result, 16%; its 24% math average was close to Christopher Columbus School #8 at 25%. Leaders also vary by grade: Madison led grade 3 in ELA and math, while Jefferson led grade 5 ELA.
Results fell broadly from 2024–25 to 2025–26: the area ELA average dropped 15 points and math dropped 17, with every school’s average declining in both subjects. Madison was a notable science exception, rising 12 points to 44% while the other five schools declined. SchoolDigger’s percentile rank for Madison fell from the 83rd in 2023–24 to the 50th in 2025–26, despite that science gain. All schools report free/reduced lunch eligible for 2024–25; Madison had the highest share at 75% and also strong science and math results. Student–teacher ratios do not neatly track results: Lincoln’s was 10.3:1 and Jefferson’s 10.1:1, yet Lincoln had the lowest ELA average while Jefferson led.
Thank you for your feedback!