Summary:
The six schools in Flemington-Raritan Regional School District serve pre-K through grade 8: four elementary schools, an intermediate school for grades 5–6, and a middle school for grades 7–8. In 2025–2026, the elementary schools averaged 8 percentage points above the state in ELA and 9 points above in math, but results varied substantially by grade and school. The clearest overall takeaway is that the area performs above state averages in elementary tests, while no single result describes every school or grade.
Barley Sheaf stands out among the elementary schools: its grade 3–4 results averaged 16 points above matching state results, compared with 1 point at Desmares. The grade-level leaders differed: Barley Sheaf led grade 3 ELA and math, at 66% and 72%, while Copper Hill led grade 4 ELA and math, at 66% and 64%. Copper Hill’s grade 3 ELA result was the lowest, at 39%; Desmares had the lowest results in grade 4 ELA (46%), grade 3 math (50%), and grade 4 math (49%). At the other grade levels, Reading-Fleming had a mixed profile: grade 6 ELA and math were 12 and 16 points above state results, while grade 5 ELA and science were slightly below. J.P. Case was below the state in regular grade 7 and 8 math by 5 and 6 points, despite strong Algebra I and Geometry end-of-course results—48 and 42 points above state results.
Year-to-year elementary changes often went in opposite directions across grades: Copper Hill’s grade 3 ELA fell 17 points while grade 4 ELA rose 5; Barley Sheaf’s grade 3 ELA rose 20 points while grade 4 ELA fell 11. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile rankings also varied: Barley Sheaf was nearly steady at 76 in 2023–2024 and 75 in 2025–2026, while J.P. Case moved from 69 to 58; rankings are not test-score trends. As context, the 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible share ranged from 18% at Barley Sheaf to 45% at Desmares, and elementary student-teacher ratios ranged from 8.7 to 10.0. The test data cover only two school years.
Thank you for your feedback!