Summary:
Elmwood Park School District includes five schools serving elementary, middle and high school grades, with a combined enrollment of 2,597. In 2025–2026, the three elementary schools averaged 43% in both ELA and math, below state averages of 49% in ELA and 47% in math. The most important finding is how sharply elementary results differ from school to school: Gantner Avenue School leads while Gilbert Avenue School trails.
Gantner Avenue School has the strongest elementary averages: 57% in ELA and 56% in math, compared with 29% and 30% at Gilbert Avenue School—gaps of 28 and 26 points. Sixteenth Avenue School falls between them overall, but stands out in grade 5 ELA, where it leads the elementary schools at 57%. At Memorial Middle School, grade 8 Algebra I is a notable exception to weaker general results: proficiency is 81%, above the state’s 75%, while grade 8 math is 11% versus 23% statewide. Memorial Senior High School has a 92% graduation rate, above the state’s 89%.
Elementary math has moved closer to the state level: the local average rose from 36% to 43% between 2024–2025 and 2025–2026, narrowing the gap from 11 points to 4. ELA moved the other way, falling from 48% to 43% as the gap widened from 2 points to 5. These shifts vary by school: Sixteenth Avenue School’s math average rose 14 points, while Gilbert Avenue School’s fell 9. SchoolDigger rates Gantner Avenue School at the 60th percentile and 3 stars, Sixteenth Avenue School at the 43rd percentile and 2 stars, and Gilbert Avenue School at the 21st percentile and 1 star. Their 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible shares were similar—57% at Gantner and 58% at Gilbert—an observation that provides context, not an explanation for their different results.
Thank you for your feedback!