Summary:
Hackettstown has four public schools: two elementary schools, a middle school and a high school, serving elementary through high school grades. Recent test results are mixed: in 21 school-grade-subject comparisons available for both years, the average gap to the state shifted from about 5 points above in 2024–2025 to about 1 point below in 2025–2026. The most important area-wide finding is that these matched results lost ground overall, though performance varies considerably by school, grade and subject.
Willow Grove Elementary School has the most consistently close-to-state profile in its available comparisons: its 2025–2026 average gaps were about 2 points above the state in ELA and 1 point below in math. Its grade 4 ELA result was 56%, 10 points above the state, while grade 3 ELA was below the state. Hackettstown High School had the standout individual result—84% proficiency in grade 9 Geometry versus 50% statewide—but its grade 11 Science result was 18%, 10 points below the state. Hackettstown Middle School had average gaps of 6 points below the state in ELA and 9 below in math; grade 5 math was 20 points below. Hatchery Hill Elementary School has no test scores in the supplied data, so its performance cannot be judged from these results.
Results declined in several areas between 2024–2025 and 2025–2026: High’s grade 11 NJGPA ELA fell 15 points and Science fell 13, while Middle’s grade 8 ELA fell 20 points. Willow Grove’s grade 3 math fell 11 points, although its current grade 4 ELA and math results were above state comparisons. SchoolDigger rankings also moved down: High fell 13 percentile points, Middle 17 and Willow Grove 7. Other measures add context, not explanations: in 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible shares were 30% at High, 46% at Middle, 45% at Willow Grove and 42% at Hatchery Hill. Student-teacher ratios ranged from 8.7 to 11.7; chronic absenteeism was highest at Hatchery Hill, at 18%.
Thank you for your feedback!