Summary:
Brookside, New Jersey, has two schools serving grades PK–8: Mendham Township Elementary School (PK–4) and Mendham Township Middle School (5–8), with 808 students combined. Their 2025–2026 results are strong across the tested grades and subjects: every reported school result is above the matching state rate. The smallest advantage is 22 percentage points in middle-school fifth-grade science, and the largest is 66 points in eighth-grade math. The clearest overall finding is that neither school has a reported test result below the state.
The middle school stands out for its eighth-grade math result: 89% proficient versus 23% statewide, a 66-point advantage; its Algebra I results are also 100% in both reported comparisons. The elementary school’s strongest listed result is third-grade ELA, at 92% versus 48% statewide, a 44-point advantage. Its lowest current result is fourth-grade ELA, at 75% versus 46% statewide, still 29 points higher. SchoolDigger gives the middle school five stars and a rank of 3rd among 743 New Jersey middle schools; the elementary school also has five stars and ranks 33rd among 1,331 elementary schools. These rankings use different school-level groups, and the schools test different grades, so they are not a direct head-to-head comparison.
Recent results show different patterns: the middle school’s four-grade ELA average fell 6 percentage points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, while its math average rose 2 points. At the elementary school, the two-grade ELA average rose 1 point and math rose 4, though grade 4 ELA fell 12 points as grade 3 ELA climbed 15. Middle-school science also moved in opposite directions by grade: fifth grade fell 13 points, while eighth grade rose 4. For context, 2024–2025 student-teacher ratios were similar—9.3 at the elementary school and 9.6 at the middle school. The elementary school reported about 1% free/reduced lunch eligible in 2023–2024, and the middle school about 1% in 2024–2025; these are different school years, not a like-year comparison.
Thank you for your feedback!