Summary:
ZIP code 03867 has three elementary schools serving kindergarten through fifth grade in the Rochester School District: Chamberlain Street School, McClelland School, and Maple Street Magnet School. Together, they enroll about 740 students, with Chamberlain and McClelland serving roughly 310 students each and Maple serving 114.
Maple Street Magnet School is the strongest overall performer in the area, with the highest current ranking and the best 2025–2026 proficiency results in mathematics and reading. About 41% of students were proficient in math and 45% in reading, placing the school close to the state math average and above the district in both subjects. Its main academic weakness is science, where proficiency was 14%. Because Maple is much smaller than the other schools, its results may fluctuate more from year to year. McClelland School ranks second but shows the most encouraging recent trend, improving from the 13th to the 21st statewide percentile over three years. It also had strong third-grade math and the highest available science performance, although reading and science remained below state averages.
Chamberlain Street School faces the greatest academic challenges. Its 2025–2026 proficiency rates were 20% in mathematics and 26% in reading, well below both district and state results, and its statewide ranking fell to the fourth percentile. Particularly weak areas include third-grade reading at 13% and fifth-grade math at 16%, though fourth-grade performance was comparatively stronger. Across the ZIP code, parents should consider Maple for its strongest current math and reading results, McClelland for its improving trajectory and relatively strong science performance, and Chamberlain’s need for more targeted academic support. All three schools remain below statewide averages overall, and science and reading are broad areas for improvement.
Thank you for your feedback!