Summary:
Zip code 58533 has two schools in Elgin-New Leipzig 49: Elgin-New Leipzig Elementary School, serving reported grades PK–6, and Elgin-New Leipzig High School, serving grades 7–12; together, they enroll 168 students. The clearest shared strength is science: in 2025–26, elementary results were 60–78% proficient versus 39% statewide, and high-school results were 80–98% versus 39% statewide.
Elgin-New Leipzig High School stands out most in reading and science: its 2025–26 results were 70–99% in reading, 13–42 points above the state, and 80–98% in science, 41–59 points above. The elementary school’s clearest grade-level standout is sixth-grade math, at least 90% proficient versus 54% statewide—at least 36 points higher. Math is the relative soft spot: elementary all-grades math was 65–73% versus 54% statewide, while the high school’s 50–68% range spans from 4 points below to 14 above. The latest results do not establish a clear all-grades math leader because the schools’ ranges overlap. Since the schools serve different grade spans and many latest all-grades scores are ranges, school-to-school comparisons are descriptive rather than direct rankings.
SchoolDigger rankings improved at both schools: the elementary school rose from the 41st percentile in 2023–24 to the 82nd in 2025–26, while the high school moved from the 71st percentile in 2021–22 to the 93rd. Test-score changes are more mixed: elementary math rose from 54% to 65–73%, and high-school math from 20% to 50–68%; meanwhile, high-school reading shifted from 100% to 70–99%. In 2024–25, the schools had similar free/reduced-lunch-eligible shares—about 55% at the elementary school and 54% at the high school—and student–teacher ratios of 10.9 and 7.5, respectively. These are useful context for comparing the schools, not explanations for their results.
Thank you for your feedback!