Summary:
Zip code 58351 has two small schools: Minnewaukan Elementary School serves prekindergarten through grade 8, and Minnewaukan High School serves grades 9–12. The clearest overall concern is that the schools’ equally weighted 2024–25 proficiency averages were below state results in all three subjects: about 18% in math versus 41% statewide, 21% in reading versus 40%, and 20% in science versus 38%; math had the largest gap, about 24 percentage points.
The standout results are in eighth grade at Minnewaukan Elementary: reading was 80–98%, compared with 54% statewide, and science was 50–79%, versus 43%. The clearest shortfalls were also at the elementary school: fifth-grade math was 10–29% against 56% statewide, and seventh-grade math was 10–29% against 52%. The high school’s 2025–26 graduation rate was 77%, about 10 points below the state’s 87%. No school is a clear all-grades leader: their 2025–26 ranges overlap in math, reading, and science, and the schools serve different grade spans.
Proficiency rose in raw terms from 2024–25 to 2025–26, but the evidence of catching up to the state is mixed. Elementary math increased from about 16% to 20–28%, while the state result rose from 41% to 54%; its reading improved from 23% to 40–48%, and science from about 20% to 30–49%. High school math and reading also rose from about 20%, but its latest ranges are too broad to show whether it narrowed the state gap. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile ranking fell for Elementary, from the 15th percentile in 2023–24 to the 6th in 2025–26, while High School rose from the 2nd to the 14th percentile. As context, in 2024–25, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 92% at Elementary and 92% at High School; student-teacher ratios were 10.8 and 11.8, respectively.
Thank you for your feedback!