Summary:
In zip code 28134, there are two public elementary schools—Sterling Elementary (grades PK–5) and Pineville Elementary (grades K–5)—both serving predominantly economically disadvantaged students within the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools district, where more than 99% of students at each school qualify for free/reduced-price lunch. Despite sharing a district and zip code, these two schools show dramatically different academic outcomes.
Pineville Elementary is the clear standout, ranking in the 62nd percentile statewide (561 out of 1,492) with a 3-star rating. It meets or exceeds North Carolina state averages in 5 of 7 grade/subject EOG categories, including strong 5th grade results: 73.5% proficient in science and 68.7% in reading. In contrast, Sterling Elementary ranks in the bottom 7% of North Carolina elementary schools (1,383 out of 1,492) with 0 stars, and falls below district and state averages in all 7 measured categories. The proficiency gap is stark—Pineville’s 5th grade reading proficiency is 37 percentage points higher than Sterling’s, and composite reading averages differ by 32 points (61.2% vs. 28.8%).
Attendance and staffing also tell a consistent story. Sterling has a 26.3% chronic absenteeism rate—near the district average—while Pineville’s is just 17.0%, well below state averages. Pineville also benefits from a lower student-teacher ratio (13.8 vs. 17.8). Sterling is improving, with 3rd grade reading rising from 13% to 26.9% and 4th grade math from 40.5% to 56.1% over the past year, but it remains critically low. The bottom line: Pineville Elementary performs solidly near or above state averages despite high poverty, while Sterling Elementary requires targeted support to close an enormous achievement gap between two neighboring schools.
Thank you for your feedback!