Summary:
Zip code 27529 in Garner, NC, is served by three traditional public middle schools—East Garner Middle, Cleveland Middle, and North Garner Middle—which together enroll about 2,876 students in grades 6-8, and all three serve very high-poverty populations, with 99.6% to 99.7% of students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch.
The clear standout is Cleveland Middle, part of Johnston County Public Schools. It earns a 4-star rating and ranks in the 72nd percentile statewide (220 of 778), outperforming the two Wake County schools in every EOG subject and grade level. Cleveland’s average EOG proficiency is about 64.7%, compared to roughly 45.7% at East Garner Middle and 45.8% at North Garner Middle. This success comes despite Cleveland having the highest student-teacher ratio (18.4:1), the lowest per-pupil spending ($7,527), and the same near-universal poverty rate. Meanwhile, East Garner and North Garner are nearly identical low performers, ranking in the bottom third of the state with 1-star ratings and scoring 10-20 points below state averages in math and reading.
The biggest differentiator is chronic absenteeism: only 18.6% at Cleveland, versus 31.0% at North Garner and 34.8% at East Garner, compared to the state average of 24.2%. Although Wake County Schools is a higher-ranked district overall than Johnston County Public Schools, the opposite is true for these specific middle schools. Higher spending and smaller class sizes in the Wake schools have not translated into better outcomes, while Cleveland has been consistently ranked in the upper half of North Carolina middle schools for three consecutive years. Science is a relative strength everywhere, with 8th-grade science proficiency at 77.7% in Cleveland, 61.7% at North Garner, and 57.4% at East Garner. For parents, Cleveland is the clear academic choice in the area, while the two Garner schools face persistent challenges that may require targeted attendance and instructional interventions.
Thank you for your feedback!