Summary:
Tate County School District in Mississippi is home to two public high schools — Independence High School and Strayhorn High School — both serving grades 7 through 12 in the rural Coldwater and Sarah communities, with enrollments of 507 and 404 students respectively. Both schools serve similarly high-poverty populations (around 70% free/reduced lunch) with comparable student-teacher ratios, yet sit well below state averages academically; the district is ranked 109th out of 134 Mississippi districts.
Across nearly every measure, Independence High School is the clear academic leader. It ranks in the 34th percentile statewide (2 stars) versus Strayhorn's 5th percentile (0 stars) and outperforms Strayhorn dramatically on high school end-of-course exams — 40.5% vs. 18.9% proficient in English II and 53.9% vs. 39.7% in Biology. Independence even exceeded state proficiency in Algebra I, Biology, and U.S. History the prior year. Strayhorn High School, by contrast, suffered a severe ranking collapse from the 40th to the 5th percentile in one year, with English II proficiency plunging 25 points. Interestingly, Strayhorn outperformed Independence in several 7th- and 8th-grade subjects in 2025–26, suggesting its students struggle most when transitioning to high-school-level coursework. Strayhorn also failed to report Algebra I data in the most recent year, leaving a key accountability gap.
Both schools face serious concerns. Chronic absenteeism runs well above the state average of 23.9% — 33.2% at Independence and 38.6% at Strayhorn — likely contributing to low achievement. Graduation rates are similar (85.7% vs. 86.7%) yet mask low proficiency in core subjects. The district as a whole is losing ground relative to the state in key areas like 7th-grade math and English II, and with poverty nearly identical across the two schools, the performance gap points to school-level factors. For parents, Independence is the stronger choice academically, while Strayhorn requires urgent attention around attendance and high school EOC performance.
Thank you for your feedback!