Summary:
Zip code 49841 in Gwinn, Michigan, is served by two elementary schools within the Gwinn Area Community Schools district, together educating roughly 415 students in a small, rural Upper Peninsula community.
For parents comparing the two schools, George D Gilbert Elementary School (grades 3-5) is the stronger academic performer, though its state ranking has slipped from the 55th to the 32nd percentile over the past two years. Its test scores remain well below state averages—for example, only 21.3% of 3rd graders are proficient in ELA versus the 38.2% state average—but it shows a relative strength in math, with 4th grade proficiency (39.0%) nearly matching the state figure. In contrast, KI Sawyer Elementary School (grades PK-5) has climbed steadily from the 14th to the 31st percentile over three years, though it lacks detailed test score data for direct comparison. KI Sawyer serves a notably more economically disadvantaged population (72% free/reduced lunch vs. 56% at Gilbert) and receives significantly more funding per student ($20,332 vs. $16,682) with a better student-teacher ratio (11.8:1 vs. 13.4:1).
Both schools face systemic challenges. Chronic absenteeism is a district-wide issue, with Gilbert at 36.1% and KI Sawyer at 28.1%—both exceeding the 27.9% state average. Interestingly, the lower-performing KI Sawyer has better attendance, suggesting poverty and early childhood factors, not attendance, drive the achievement gap. Gilbert's 5th grade social studies proficiency (14.5%) is particularly concerning at roughly half the state average, while its test scores fluctuate year-to-year, indicating cohort or instructional instability. KI Sawyer's location near the former Air Force base hints at a community still adapting to economic transition. Overall, parents should expect both schools to trail state averages significantly, with Gilbert offering stronger academics but higher absenteeism, and KI Sawyer providing more resources per student and steady improvement from a low base.
Thank you for your feedback!