Summary:
Zip code 49686 is home to two high schools within the Traverse City Area Public Schools district: Central High School, a large traditional school serving grades 8-12 with 1,326 students, and Traverse City High School, a much smaller alternative school serving grades 9-12 with 171 students.
Central High School is the clear standout, ranking in the top 12% of Michigan high schools (96th of 800) and earning a 4-star rating. Its graduation rate is exceptional at 95.4%, far exceeding the state average of 84%, and its dropout rate is just 2.7%. Academically, Central excels, with 68.9% of 11th graders proficient in SAT Reading and Writing and 51.9% proficient in SAT Math—nearly double the state average of 26.5%. In contrast, Traverse City High School ranks in the bottom quarter of the state (588th of 800) with a 1-star rating. Its graduation rate is a troubling 46.7%, less than half of Central's, and its dropout rate of 13% is nearly five times higher. Chronic absenteeism affects 38.9% of Traverse City students, compared to 20.2% at Central.
The two schools serve very different populations, with 59.65% of Traverse City High School students eligible for free/reduced lunch versus 20.29% at Central. Notably, Traverse City High School actually spends more per student ($16,076 vs. $13,463) and has a better student-teacher ratio (16.3:1 vs. 23.6:1), yet outcomes remain dramatically lower. Central's test scores in science (37.8%) and social studies (42.7%) also outpace Traverse City's (22.9% in both subjects). For parents, this zip code offers a stark choice: a high-achieving, traditional college-preparatory experience at Central, or an alternative setting at Traverse City High School that serves students who have struggled in conventional environments, though with significantly lower academic and graduation outcomes.
Thank you for your feedback!