Summary:
There are six elementary schools serving grades PK-5 in zip code 48706, which covers the Bay City, Michigan area and is split between the Bay City School District and Bangor Township Schools.
For parents, the standout choice is Mackensen Elementary School, which holds the highest state ranking (55th percentile) and is the only school to maintain a 3-star rating for three straight years. It leads in 4th-grade math (45.8% proficient) and 4th-grade ELA (50% proficient), while also having the lowest poverty rate (36.23% free/reduced lunch) and a relatively low chronic absenteeism rate (19.9%). Kolb Elementary School is a close competitor, ranking in the 57th percentile and posting the best 3rd-grade scores in both ELA (48.2%) and math (49.4%), despite having the highest poverty rate (72.51%). Among Bangor Township schools, Bangor West Central School (51st percentile) and Bangor Lincoln School (50th percentile) perform comparably to the Bay City schools, with Bangor Lincoln excelling in 5th-grade science (48.3% proficient). McAlearSawden Elementary School sits in the middle (39th percentile). The clear outlier is Bangor Central School, which dropped from a 3-star to a 1-star rating (16th percentile) and now posts the lowest scores across nearly all subjects, with 5th-grade ELA falling to just 19.3% proficiency.
Key takeaways: Higher spending and smaller class sizes in Bay City schools (ratios around 14:1) do not guarantee better results than Bangor Township schools (ratios around 25:1), as outcomes are mixed within each district. Bangor Central’s sharp decline—5th-grade math plummeting from 37.7% to 17.9% in one year—warrants attention. Socioeconomic status is a strong indicator, but Kolb’s success despite its high poverty rate shows effective support programs can make a difference. Chronic absenteeism is a concern, with Bangor Central at 29.0%, though most schools stay below the state average of 27.9%.
Thank you for your feedback!