Best Public Schools in Zip Code 48458

The 8 schools in zip code 48458, serving the Mount Morris area, are all part of the Mt. Morris Consolidated Schools district and include three elementary schools, one middle school, three high schools, and one alternative school, with a total enrollment of about 1,427 students.

For parents, the most important takeaway is that this district faces severe academic challenges, particularly in math. At Mt Morris Middle School, only about 4% of students are proficient in math, which is roughly 12 times below the state average, and this represents a dramatic drop from the already-low elementary levels at schools like Moore Elementary School and Montague Elementary School. Chronic absenteeism is also a major issue, with nearly half of all students missing significant school time—Pinehurst Early Elementary and Mt Morris Middle School both exceed 51%. However, there are bright spots: EA Johnson Memorial High School posts a graduation rate of 85.1%, above the state average, despite serving a high-poverty population. Montague Elementary has shown consistent year-over-year improvement in state rankings, and Mt Morris Education and Community Center, an alternative program, actually outperformed the traditional high school in science and social studies proficiency.

The district is overwhelmingly low-income, with 70-92% of students at traditional schools qualifying for free or reduced lunch, and it also operates two institutional facilities—Genesee County Juvenile Justice Center and Genesee County Jail—which serve incarcerated youth and have extremely low graduation rates. While per-student spending appears competitive, there is no clear link between spending and outcomes, suggesting the core issues are instructional quality and student support. For parents, the data points to a district in need of urgent intervention, especially in early math instruction and attendance, but one where individual schools like EA Johnson and Montague demonstrate that improvement is possible.