Summary:
Zip code 48203, serving the Detroit and Highland Park areas, is home to two middle schools—Greenfield Union ElementaryMiddle School (grades 2-8, 185 students) and George Washington Carver Middle School (grades 5-8, 155 students)—both serving predominantly low-income families with free/reduced lunch rates above 91%.
For parents comparing the two, Greenfield Union holds a clear academic edge overall, ranking in the 25th percentile statewide versus Carver’s 5th percentile. Greenfield’s standout subject is 8th grade Social Studies, where 47.1% proficiency nearly doubles its Detroit Public Schools Community District average and approaches the state rate. However, Greenfield struggles with chronic absenteeism at 64.5%—far above the state’s 27.9%—while George Washington Carver Middle School posts a much healthier 35.8% rate despite serving an even higher-poverty population (99.35% free/reduced lunch). Carver also edges out Greenfield on 8th grade PSAT English Language Arts (35.5% vs. 33.3%), suggesting its students perform relatively well on college-readiness assessments. Carver’s scores closely mirror its George Washington Carver Academy district averages, while Greenfield shows more variability—sometimes exceeding its district by 20 points, sometimes falling below.
Both schools face significant achievement gaps, typically running 20-30 percentage points behind state averages in core subjects like ELA and math. Greenfield spends an extraordinary $27,183 per student—roughly 2-3 times the national average—yet outcomes remain modest, raising questions about resource efficiency. Carver’s trajectory is concerning, dropping from the 15th to 5th percentile between 2024-2026, possibly due to its transition to a grades 5-8 configuration. Parents should weigh Greenfield’s stronger academics and social studies program against its severe absenteeism problem, while Carver offers better attendance and a smaller, more consistent environment—but with lower overall test scores and a declining trend.
Thank you for your feedback!