Summary
Holden Elementary School in Sterling Heights, MI, is a mid-sized PK-6 school within the Warren Consolidated Schools district, serving 341 students in a predominantly low-income area, with over 83% of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch.
Academically, Holden faces significant challenges, ranking in the bottom half of Michigan elementary schools with a current 1-star rating. The most striking finding is the stark contrast with nearby Troy School District schools like Wass Elementary and Costello Elementary, located just a mile or two away. These schools consistently rank in the 90th+ percentile, with proficiency rates often double or triple Holden's. For example, in 5th-grade math, Holden's proficiency was 20.3%, while Wass and Costello achieved 64.3% and 70.1%, respectively. This academic gap mirrors a socio-economic divide—Troy schools have free/reduced lunch rates below 18%, compared to Holden's 83%. Notably, Holden spends over $22,000 per student, significantly more than the high-performing Troy schools (ranging from $15,000–$18,000) and even its district peers like Harwood Elementary ($14,937), yet this higher spending has not translated into higher test scores.
Performance at Holden is inconsistent across grades and subjects. A bright spot emerged in 4th-grade ELA, where proficiency reached 50% in 2023-2024—above the state average—though this success was not sustained. Math remains a persistent weakness, especially in upper grades. Subgroup data reveals concerning trends, including a dramatic decline for male students (from the 41st to 13th percentile) and critically low performance for White students (3rd percentile). However, the school showed relative strength in supporting its low-income students in prior years, ranking in the 52nd–58th percentile, though this slipped recently. On a positive note, chronic absenteeism at 19.2% is significantly better than the district average of 34.4%, suggesting attendance is a foundation the school can build upon.
Thank you for your feedback!