Summary:
The Saginaw Township Community Schools district in Michigan contains two high schools serving grades 9-12: Heritage High School with 1,313 students and Mackinaw High School with just 138 students, making Heritage nearly ten times larger.
These two schools serve very different purposes and student populations. Heritage High School is the district's traditional comprehensive high school, posting a strong 90.9% graduation rate versus Mackinaw's 35.4%, and a much lower dropout rate (2.8% vs. 24.1%). Heritage also has far better attendance, with 28.4% chronic absenteeism compared to Mackinaw's crisis-level 93.9%. While Heritage earns a 3-star state rating (55th percentile), Mackinaw sits at 1 star (24th percentile). However, Mackinaw serves a much higher-need population, with 73.91% of students qualifying for free/reduced lunch versus 38.16% at Heritage, and it appears to function as an alternative program for students who struggled in traditional settings. Mackinaw actually spends more per student ($16,256 vs. $13,573) yet has a higher student-teacher ratio (23:1 vs. 19.5:1), suggesting funds go toward support services rather than smaller classes.
Academically, Heritage outperforms Mackinaw in nearly every subject, though both struggle with math. Heritage's 9th-grade PSAT math proficiency (20.9%) is far below the state average (33.5%), and its SAT math scores (24.4%) also lag the state (26.5%). Reading scores are much stronger, with Heritage's SAT EBRW proficiency at 52.3% versus just 24.4% in math. Mackinaw shows surprising strengths in science and social studies when students do attend, with 11th-grade science proficiency (39.1%) exceeding both district and state averages. Mackinaw's state ranking is highly volatile due to its small size, swinging from the 26th to 72th percentile and back to 24th in three years. Overall, Saginaw Township Community Schools ranks in the middle of Michigan districts (2 stars), with Heritage driving most positive outcomes while Mackinaw's challenges pull down district-wide metrics.
Thank you for your feedback!