Summary:
Ithaca Public Schools is a small, rural district in central Michigan serving approximately 971 students in grades PK-12 across three buildings: South Elementary School (PK-2), North Elementary School (3-6), and Ithaca High School (7-12). The district overall earns a 4-star rating, ranking in the 73rd percentile of Michigan districts, but that strong reputation is driven almost entirely by the high school.
Ithaca High School is the clear standout, ranking in the 84th percentile of Michigan high schools with a 96.9% graduation rate and zero dropouts. Its 11th graders outperform the state by nearly 30 points in social studies (73.1% vs. 43.2% proficient) and by 17 points in science, while SAT reading/writing proficiency sits at 73.1% versus the state's 52.1%. In contrast, North Elementary School (3-6) holds only a 2-star rating, with notable weaknesses in 4th grade math (23.2% proficient vs. 39.4% statewide) and 4th grade ELA (30.4% vs. 41.3%). South Elementary School (PK-2) has no test scores, but its 29.3% chronic absenteeism rate is a red flag, exceeding both the district average (21.1%) and the state average (27.9%).
Families should note the stark academic disconnect between the high school and its feeder elementary schools, suggesting significant growth occurs during the 7th-8th grade years housed within the high school building. The district also shows socioeconomic variation, with free/reduced lunch rates of 35.5% at the high school versus roughly 50% at both elementary schools. Per-student spending is highest at South Elementary ($15,228) and lowest at the high-performing high school ($13,952), reflecting smaller class sizes for younger students. While North Elementary shows volatile year-over-year scores—likely due to small cohorts—the high school's consistent excellence in science, social studies, and verbal skills makes it a strong choice for college-bound students, even as math proficiency (38.8% on SAT) remains a relative weak point.
Thank you for your feedback!