Summary:
Imlay City Middle School is the sole middle school serving grades 6-8 in the Imlay City Community Schools district, located in a small, largely rural Michigan community where 55.4% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Because this is the district’s only middle school, its performance directly defines the district’s reputation. The school’s standout strength is 8th-grade Social Studies, where 63.6% of students are proficient—13.3 percentage points above the state average. Eighth-grade PSAT English Language Arts is also a bright spot, with 75% proficiency versus 64.8% statewide. However, math is a clear weakness: only 23.7% of 6th graders and 30.1% of 7th graders are proficient on the M-Step, both below state averages, and 8th-grade PSAT math (31.8%) also trails the state. Science proficiency (38.8%) is essentially at the state level.
Recent trends are concerning. The school’s state ranking has slipped from the 71st percentile (4 stars) in 2023-2024 to the 60th percentile (3 stars) in 2025-2026. Year-over-year declines appear in 6th and 7th-grade math, 8th-grade science, and 8th-grade Social Studies, with only 7th-grade ELA improving. Chronic absenteeism affects 28.4% of students—slightly above the state rate—which likely hampers progress, especially in cumulative subjects like math. The stark gap between strong 8th-grade PSAT ELA (75%) and weaker 6th/7th-grade M-Step ELA (31.7% and 35.7%) suggests literacy instruction may become more effective in later grades, or that test formats differ significantly. With per-student spending at $15,685, the school has solid resources, yet math outcomes remain below average, pointing to potential opportunities for targeted math intervention and professional development. For parents, this school offers clear strengths in social studies and later-grade reading, but math proficiency and consistent year-over-year growth are areas to watch closely.
Thank you for your feedback!