Summary:
The Cedar Springs Public Schools district in Michigan operates two high schools serving grades 9-12: Cedar Springs High School (CSHS), a large traditional school with 952 students, and New Beginnings Alternative High School (NBAHS), a small alternative program with just 50 students. The district overall ranks in the top 21% of Michigan districts with a 4-star rating.
These two schools serve very different purposes, and their metrics reflect that. Cedar Springs High School is the district's academic flagship, earning a 4-star rating and ranking in the top 20% of all Michigan high schools. Its graduation rate is an impressive 93%, compared to just 45.9% at New Beginnings Alternative High School, and its dropout rate is 3.1% versus 18.9% at the alternative school. CSHS also dramatically outperforms state averages on assessments—for example, 56.3% of its 11th graders are proficient in science versus 34.9% statewide. Chronic absenteeism at CSHS is 17.7%, far below the state's 27.9%, while NBAHS struggles with a 64% chronic absenteeism rate. The alternative school also serves a higher percentage of economically disadvantaged students (54% free/reduced lunch vs. 29.7% at CSHS) and spends more per student ($17,533 vs. $14,209), reflecting the intensive support services needed for its at-risk population.
For parents, the key takeaway is that Cedar Springs High School is a consistently high-performing, stable school—its state percentile ranking has held between 78th and 85th over three years—making it an excellent choice for students seeking a rigorous traditional education. New Beginnings Alternative High School, by contrast, is designed for students who have not succeeded in a traditional setting, offering a smaller, more supportive environment despite lower outcome metrics. Because CSHS enrolls 95% of the district's high school students, the district's strong overall performance is driven almost entirely by CSHS, so parents should look at each school individually rather than relying on district averages.
Thank you for your feedback!