Summary:
Caro Community Schools operates two elementary campuses in Caro, Michigan, serving a combined 616 students in grades PK-5 across McComb Elementary School (PK-2) and Schall Elementary School (3-5), with both schools facing significant economic challenges as over 60% of students qualify for free/reduced lunch.
These two schools split grade levels, creating distinct profiles. McComb Elementary serves the youngest students with a more favorable student-teacher ratio of 12.6:1 and higher per-student spending at $17,102, reflecting a strategic investment in early education. However, it also reports higher chronic absenteeism at 24.0%. In contrast, Schall Elementary operates more efficiently at $15,033 per student with a 16.2:1 ratio, yet achieves notably better attendance at 18.6% — well below the state average of 27.9%. Both schools outperform district and state averages for chronic absenteeism, suggesting strong family engagement despite economic hardships.
Academically, Schall Elementary provides the only standardized test data, and the picture is mixed with a concerning downward trend. The school's state ranking has slipped from the 44th to 38th percentile over three years. Most alarming is 3rd-grade ELA proficiency, which plummeted from 35.6% to 22.4% — a 13-point drop leaving students 16 points below state averages. Social studies is another critical weakness at 16.4% proficiency, far below the 27.5% state average. However, there are bright spots: 5th-grade science exceeds the state average (40.9% vs. 40.0%), and math performance nearly matches state levels in grades 4 and 5. The district's investment in early education at McComb may not be translating into later success, as the higher absenteeism in early grades could undermine those efforts. Parents should note that while Schall struggles in ELA and social studies, its science program offers a model of success, and the district's attendance initiatives appear effective despite socioeconomic challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!