Summary:
Caledonia Community Schools is a top-ranked Michigan district (13th out of 625) serving about 4,561 students across 8 schools: five elementary schools (K-4, one with Pre-K), two middle schools (grades 5-6 and 7-8), and one high school (9-12).
For parents, the standout elementary school is Kettle Lake Elementary School, which posted the district’s highest single-subject score—87% proficiency in 4th grade math—and ranks in the 98th percentile statewide. However, Dutton Elementary School is the rising star, improving from #66 to #32 in state rankings and achieving the best 3rd grade scores in the district (84.5% ELA, 87.9% math) despite serving the highest percentage of economically disadvantaged students (28.4% free/reduced lunch). In contrast, Paris Ridge Elementary is the area of concern, with 3rd grade ELA dropping 22.5 points to 55.3% and its ranking falling to #149—though it still earns a 5-star rating and outperforms 90% of Michigan schools. At the secondary level, Caledonia High School posts strong SAT scores (69.4% ELA, 39.5% math) and a 91.8% graduation rate, but its 46.1% chronic absenteeism rate is more than double the district average and warrants investigation.
Key takeaways for families: Math proficiency drops sharply between 4th grade (75-87%) and 5th grade at Kraft Meadows Intermediate School (52.7%), though 8th grade PSAT scores at Duncan Lake Middle School rebound to 65.4%. ELA skills remain strong across all grades, showing solid vertical alignment. Spending per student varies from $14,193 (Kettle Lake) to $16,495 (Dutton), but higher spending doesn’t guarantee better results—Paris Ridge spends $16,247 yet shows the weakest performance. Overall, even the district’s “lowest” performing school is exceptional, making Caledonia a reliable choice for consistently high-quality education across all grade levels.
Thank you for your feedback!