Summary:
The four elementary schools in the Brighton Area Schools district—Hornung Elementary School, Hawkins Elementary School, Spencer Road Elementary School, and Hilton Road Elementary School—serve grades K-4 in an affluent suburban area, with the district ranking in the 96th percentile statewide and earning a 5-star rating.
For parents, the standout choice is Hornung Elementary School, which ranks highest (80th of 1,492 schools, 95th percentile) and shows remarkable consistency, leading all schools in 4th-grade proficiency with 74.3% in ELA and 79.6% in Math. It also achieves these results while spending the least per student ($13,402) and having the largest class sizes, suggesting exceptional efficiency. Spencer Road Elementary School is a close second (97th statewide), with particular strength in math—3rd-grade at 74.3% and 4th-grade at 74.5%—and posted exceptional 4th-grade scores in 2024-2025 (78.3% ELA, 81.5% Math). Hilton Road Elementary School shows the most dramatic improvement, jumping 79 positions in state rankings to 91st, and leads all schools in 3rd-grade proficiency (63.2% ELA, 75.8% Math). Hawkins Elementary School lags behind its peers, ranking 265th (82nd percentile), with a notable "4th-grade slump"—ELA drops from 61.0% in 3rd grade to just 48.6% in 4th grade, and Math falls to 57.0%, well below district averages.
All four schools dramatically outperform state averages, with 4th-grade Math proficiency ranging from 57.0% to 79.6% versus the state's 39.4%. Chronic absenteeism (9.3%–11.3%) is roughly one-third the state rate (27.9%). While 3rd-grade performance is fairly uniform across schools (a 5.1-point spread in ELA), 4th-grade shows wide divergence (a 25.7-point spread), suggesting school-level factors matter more as students advance. Year-over-year volatility is common—for instance, Hilton Road's 3rd-grade Math jumped 19.1 points—likely reflecting cohort differences rather than systemic changes. Despite district-wide excellence, the gap between Hornung (80th) and Hawkins (265th) spans 185 state ranking positions, highlighting that individual school leadership significantly impacts outcomes even within a top-tier district.
Thank you for your feedback!