Summary:
Bear Lake Schools is a small, rural Michigan district serving roughly 280 students in pre-kindergarten through 12th grade across two schools on a shared campus: Bear Lake Elementary School (grades PK-6) and Bear Lake High School (grades 7-12). About 61% of students qualify for free/reduced lunch, and the district earns a 3-star rating overall.
The elementary school is the clear academic standout. In 2025-2026, it earned a 4-star rating and ranked in the 71st percentile statewide. Its students consistently beat state averages in English language arts by 11 to 17 points in grades 3 through 6, and math proficiency in grades 3 and 4 exceeds state levels by more than 20 points. However, math performance drops sharply after 4th grade—by 6th grade, only 19% of students are proficient, which is nearly 13 points below the state average. The high school is far more volatile. It earned just 1 star in 2023-2024, jumped to 4 stars in 2024-2025, then fell back to 2 stars in 2025-2026. While 7th graders posted exceptional scores (73% in ELA and 67% in math, both more than 30 points above state averages), performance erodes by 10th grade, where PSAT scores lag the state by 12 to 17 points.
Graduation and attendance are major concerns. The high school’s graduation rate is just 69.5%—14.5 points below the state—and its dropout rate of 13% is nearly double the state average. Chronic absenteeism affects 29% of elementary students and 25% of high school students. Despite spending roughly $22,000 to $23,000 per student—well above typical Michigan levels—the secondary school struggles to convert resources into results. Social studies is a weak spot at both levels, and math proficiency declines steadily from 5th grade onward. The district’s small cohorts (about 22 students per grade) cause large year-to-year swings, making it hard to separate real trends from the impact of a few students.
Thank you for your feedback!