Summary:
Saginaw Preparatory Academy is a single public elementary school (PK-8) in Saginaw, Michigan, serving 376 students within the Saginaw Preparatory Academy district, where nearly all students (97%) come from economically disadvantaged households.
This school faces severe academic and attendance challenges. State testing shows proficiency rates that are 25 to 35 percentage points below Michigan averages in nearly every subject and grade. For example, only 5.77% of 3rd graders and 6.67% of 4th graders are proficient in English Language Arts, compared to state averages of 38.2% and 41.3%, respectively. Math proficiency for 3rd grade is just 7.69% versus the state's 42.9%. The school ranks in the bottom 5% of all Michigan elementary schools, with its percentile slipping from 5th to 4th over the past three years. A critical factor is chronic absenteeism: 56.2% of students miss significant instructional time, more than double the state average of 27.9%. This attendance crisis directly undermines learning, making it difficult for any curriculum to take hold.
Despite spending $13,176 per student—a reasonable amount—and maintaining a student-teacher ratio of 18.8:1, performance is declining. Year-over-year, 4th grade ELA dropped by 9.4 points, and 8th grade PSAT scores fell by 13 points. The only relative bright spot is 5th grade, which posts the school's highest M-Step scores (14.81% in ELA, Science, and Social Studies), though still far below state norms. The 8th grade PSAT ELA rate of 37% is notably higher than other grades, possibly reflecting student maturation. For parents, this school is in academic crisis, where poverty and absenteeism create barriers that funding alone cannot solve. Meaningful improvement will require intensive, wraparound support addressing attendance, family needs, and early literacy, not just standard classroom instruction.
Thank you for your feedback!