Summary:
Pontiac Academy for Excellence MiddleHigh is the sole school in the Pontiac Academy for Excellence district, a public charter serving 553 students in grades 6-12 in Pontiac, MI, where every student qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch.
This single-school district faces severe academic and engagement challenges. Proficiency rates are dramatically below Michigan averages across every subject and grade level. For example, 7th-grade math proficiency is just 6.67% versus the state’s 33.3%, and 8th-grade science is 8.33% compared to 39.2% statewide. The school’s district ranks in the bottom 1% of Michigan districts (616th out of 625) with a 0-star rating. Chronic absenteeism is a critical issue, affecting 64.2% of students—more than double the state rate of 27.9%. The dropout rate of 17.2% is also more than double the state’s 7.1%, while the graduation rate (82.7%) sits just below the state average (84.0%).
Despite these struggles, a few patterns emerge. Students who persist into upper grades show relatively better performance—11th-grade science proficiency (11.54%) and social studies (15.38%) exceed lower-grade scores, suggesting some interventions may help retained students. However, a sharp “middle school cliff” appears between 5th and 7th grade, with ELA proficiency dropping from 26.8% to 8.77% in the 2024-2025 school year. Math is the weakest subject across all grades, with 10th-grade math proficiency at just 7.69% versus 23.1% in ELA. The data also lacks spending-per-student figures, limiting insight into resource allocation. For parents, this school offers a small, close-knit environment but carries significant risks: high absenteeism, very low test scores, and a high likelihood of students not graduating. The consistent underperformance suggests systemic issues that would require substantial, targeted reform to improve outcomes.
Thank you for your feedback!