Summary:
Pomfret, Maryland, is home to two public schools within the Charles County Public Schools district: Maurice J. McDonough High School (grades 9-12) and Dr. James Craik Elementary School (Pre-K through 5th grade).
These two schools present a stark contrast in academic performance. Dr. James Craik Elementary School is a standout, significantly outperforming both the district and state averages in Mathematics, with 32.7% of students proficient compared to just 17% for the district. It also excels in Science, with 37.1% of 5th graders proficient versus the district's 23.4%. In contrast, Maurice J. McDonough High School shows a dramatic imbalance: while it is a literacy powerhouse with 68.6% of students proficient in English Language Arts, it struggles profoundly in Mathematics, where only 3.5% of all students are proficient. The high school does boast a strong graduation rate of 90.5%, but its chronic absenteeism rate of 30.1% is alarmingly high—nearly double the elementary school's rate of 16.9%.
Both schools serve similar populations of economically disadvantaged students, with about 40% receiving free or reduced lunch. The district spends over $18,000 per student at each school, yet the high school's poor math performance and high absenteeism show that spending alone does not guarantee success. The elementary school's strong results suggest effective teaching strategies are in place, but this success does not carry over to the high school level, pointing to a systemic breakdown in math education between 5th and 9th grade. For parents, Dr. James Craik Elementary is a clear district leader, while Maurice J. McDonough High School offers strong literacy and graduation rates but faces critical challenges in math and student engagement.
Thank you for your feedback!