Summary:
Zip code 42701 has 17 schools: 7 elementary, 3 middle, 4 high schools and 3 alternative schools, offering options from elementary through high school as well as alternative settings. In 2025–2026, the 11 non-alternative schools averaged 46% proficient across matched grade-and-subject results, compared with 43% statewide, a 3-point advantage. The area average was above the state in all six subjects, but the most important finding is that this modest overall lead hides substantial differences between schools.
Elizabethtown High School stands out in several high-school subjects: it led John Hardin High School in grade-11 science (34% to 28%), writing (71% to 63%), social studies (56% to 46%) and editing and mechanics (63% to 51%); John Hardin led in grade-10 math and reading. East Hardin Middle School led or tied for the lead in most middle-school comparisons, including grade-8 math at 56% and reading at 53%, while Talton K Stone Middle School led grade-8 writing at 64%, versus 48% statewide. Among elementary schools, Lincoln Trail Elementary led grades 3–5 math; Heartland Elementary excelled in reading and grade-4 science but had just 9% proficient in grade-5 writing. New Highland Elementary was below the state in every listed elementary result, including math at 24% in grade 3 and 26% in grade 5, versus 43% statewide.
Results softened overall: the combined local average fell from 47% in 2024–2025 to 46% in 2025–2026, while the state average stayed near 43%, narrowing the local advantage from 4 points to 3. Writing was a major weakness in that shift, with the local average dropping 7 points. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile ranking for New Highland fell from the 37th to the 17th percentile, while Elizabethtown High School rose from the 74th to the 91st. As context, in 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible rates were 41% at Lincoln Trail and 63% at New Highland; these figures describe school communities, not the cause of their results.
Thank you for your feedback!