Summary:
Five schools in zip code 42539 serve students from elementary through high school and enroll 2,179 students, from 312 at Jones Park Elementary to 630 at Casey County High School. The clearest overall concern is that elementary-school averages in 2025–2026 were below state results in every subject with complete, comparable data: by 6 points in math, 8 in reading, 7 in grade 4 science, 8 in grade 5 social studies and 14 in grade 5 editing and mechanics.
Liberty Elementary School is the most consistent elementary standout, leading or tying for the lead in five reported grade-and-subject comparisons. It scored 49% in grade 5 math, compared with 31% at Walnut Hill Elementary School and 19% at Jones Park—a 30-point spread. Walnut Hill has notable strengths of its own: it leads elementary reading in grades 3 and 4, and its grade 4 science result, 41%, is just above the state’s 40%. Jones Park is lowest in nearly all reported elementary math and reading comparisons; its grade 5 writing result is state-suppressed and cannot be compared. Casey County High pairs a 96% graduation rate with proficiency below the state in five of six reported subjects; its reading result, 41%, is close to writing at 46%, while state figures are 49% and 47%.
Recent changes are mixed: the elementary math gap with the state widened from 3 points to 6, and the reading gap from 4 to 8, between 2024–2025 and 2025–2026; at Casey County Middle School, the math gap narrowed from 11 points to 6 and the reading gap from 11 to 5. Jones Park’s grade 5 math and reading fell 32 and 38 points in one year, respectively, while Liberty’s grade 5 math rose 6 points. SchoolDigger’s latest statewide rankings place Liberty at the 43rd percentile and Jones Park at the 9th; Jones Park fell from the 56th percentile the year before. As context, all five schools report free/reduced lunch eligible for 2024–2025, with rates from 65% to 78%; reported student-teacher ratios range from 13.1 at Walnut Hill to 15.2 at Casey County High.
Thank you for your feedback!