Summary:
Zip code 41465 has five schools serving elementary, middle and high school grades, with 1,902 students enrolled across the area. The clearest concern is at Magoffin County High School: it fell below state proficiency results in all six reported subjects in 2025–2026, including 16% proficiency in grade 10 math versus 40% statewide.
Salyersville Grade School has the strongest cluster of elementary results, especially in grade 5: 56% were proficient in social studies, compared with 38% statewide, and 60% in editing and mechanics, compared with 48% statewide. But its grade 5 writing result was 21%, below the state’s 35%. South Magoffin Elementary stands out in grade 6 reading at 60%, 6 points above the state, though it had weaker results in other areas, including 22% in grade 3 math. Across the elementary schools, results averaged 37% in math and 50% in reading, versus 43% and 51% statewide; reported grade 5 writing averaged 19%, against 35% statewide. Herald Whitaker Middle School was near or above state results in grade 7, but grade 8 writing was 33%, 15 points below the state.
Herald Whitaker has the clearest recent test-score gains: from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, grade 7 reading rose 25 points, from 28% to 53%, and math rose 16 points, from 20% to 36%. SchoolDigger’s percentile ranking also rose from 19 to 37 for Herald Whitaker and from 42 to 52 for Salyersville between 2023–2024 and 2025–2026; rankings fell from 59 to 33 at South Magoffin and from 39 to 31 at North Magoffin. Attendance is a notable concern across the area: chronic absenteeism ranged from 45% at Herald Whitaker to 77% at the high school, compared with 24% statewide. The reported free/reduced lunch eligible shares in 2024–2025 ranged from 66% at the high school to 79% at North Magoffin Elementary; student-teacher ratios ranged from 11.3 at Herald Whitaker to 17.3 at South Magoffin. These figures offer context, not a simple explanation for school results.
Thank you for your feedback!