Summary:
ZIP code 40403 has nine schools: four elementary, three middle and two high schools, with eight in Madison County and the three Berea Community schools in Berea Independent. In 2025–2026 KSA results, the area includes schools with strong results across subjects as well as schools often below state rates. The widest differences are in middle school: in Grade 8 math, Farristown Middle School scored 67%, compared with 21% at Berea Community Middle School, a 46-point gap; Grade 8 writing showed a 45-point gap. The most important finding for families is that results vary substantially between schools, even at the same grade level.
Madison Southern High School and Farristown stand out for consistently strong results: both were above state rates in every reported 2025–2026 subject, by 6 to 26 points at Madison Southern and 7 to 29 points at Farristown. Madison Southern led the two high schools in four of six subjects, while Berea Community High School led in Grade 11 social studies, 63% to 54%. Among elementary schools, Shannon Johnson Elementary School had top results in several comparisons, including Grade 3 reading at 64% against a 49% state rate. At the other end, Berea Community Elementary was below the state in 8 of 10 reported results, as was Berea Community Middle among middle-school results.
Recent results moved in different directions, but overall the schools’ average change across 80 matched results was a 3-point decline, while state results were nearly unchanged. Berea Community High improved its position relative to the state by 8 points on average, and Madison Southern by 4; Berea Community Elementary’s relative position fell by 8 points. SchoolDigger’s 2025–2026 rankings placed Madison Southern 10th of 262 high schools and Farristown 27th of 326 middle schools; these are SchoolDigger rankings, separate from the test comparisons. As context, all schools reported free/reduced lunch eligible for school year 2024–2025, with shares from 45% at Farristown to 69% at Berea Community Elementary. High test results also do not mean attendance is strong: chronic absenteeism was 31% at Madison Southern and 34% at Berea Community High, above the 24% state rate. Results are school-level figures and do not show individual students’ experiences.
Thank you for your feedback!