Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 40218 include nine schools—three elementary schools, one middle school and five high schools—serving elementary grades through high school, including grades 6–12; enrollment ranges from 20 to 615 students. Across the elementary schools, average 2025–26 proficiency was below the state in every listed subject, with gaps of about 7 to 23 percentage points. Newburg Middle was also below state results in every listed subject and grade, while Newcomer Academy recorded 3% in 10th-grade reading compared with 49% statewide. The main takeaway is that standout results exist, but the area’s overall proficiency levels are generally below the state’s.
Klondike Lane Elementary has the strongest overall elementary profile: it reached 36% in fifth-grade reading, compared with 16% at Price Elementary, and its 41% in fifth-grade writing was the only reported elementary result above the state’s 35%. Price had the lowest reported fifth-grade reading, social studies and editing-and-mechanics results, at 16%, 12% and 19%, respectively, though it led third-grade math with 28%, versus 24% at the other two schools. Watterson Elementary led third-grade reading at 32% but had the lowest fourth-grade science result, 10%. Liberty High led the available 10th-grade math results at 13%, compared with 10% at Newcomer; other high-school results are suppressed, so those are not complete rankings.
Recent trends are mixed: the matched elementary math average fell from 24% to 19% between 2024–25 and 2025–26, while reading rose from 25% to 27%. At Newburg, average reading stayed about 30%, but eighth-grade reading fell 8 points even as sixth- and seventh-grade reading improved. SchoolDigger ranked Newcomer 262nd of 262 statewide, Price 661st of 684 and Watterson 650th of 684 in 2025–26. Context also varies: elementary student-teacher ratios range from 12.7 at Watterson to 16.7 at Price, and free/reduced lunch eligible shares in 2024–25 ranged from 69.5% at Klondike Lane to 75.5% at Price; these measures do not by themselves explain achievement. Attendance differs sharply too: chronic absenteeism was 86% at Minor Daniels Academy and 84% at Liberty, compared with 23.5% statewide, while Brooklawn was at 22.8%.
Thank you for your feedback!