Summary:
Seven elementary schools in ZIP code 40211, all in Jefferson County, serve tested grades 3–5; some also offer pre-K, while others begin in kindergarten. The latest results are for 2025–2026. Across the available school scores, average proficiency was 25% in math compared with 43% statewide, 27% in reading versus 50%, and 16% in grade-four science versus 40%; writing was closer at 30% versus 35%. The most important finding is that even the area’s strongest results generally remain below state proficiency, with especially large gaps in reading and science.
Brandeis Elementary is the clearest overall standout: it led all reported math and reading results across grades 3–5, as well as reported science and social studies. Its math scores were 6 points above the next-highest school in each grade; its reading lead ranged from 10 to 21 points. Yet Brandeis remained 2–15 points below state math rates and 3–4 points below state reading rates. Carter Traditional Elementary stands out in writing and editing: its 41% fifth-grade writing result was 6 points above the state rate and 11 points above the next-highest local score, and its 40% editing result led the group. At the lower end of published scores, Kennedy Elementary had the lowest third-grade reading score at 6%, 39 points behind Brandeis. Cane Run Elementary had the lowest third-grade math score at 9%, while King Elementary and Maupin Elementary had the lowest reported fourth-grade math and fifth-grade social studies results, respectively.
Recent changes are mixed: across 31 matched school results, scores were essentially unchanged on average, while comparable state results rose about 1 point, widening the relative gap by about 1 point. Carter averaged a 2-point gain across its matched results, while Brandeis averaged a 3-point decline. SchoolDigger ranks Brandeis 478th of 684 statewide, ahead of Carter (578th), Foster Traditional Academy (628th), and the other schools with 2025–2026 rankings. Staffing and income measures offer additional context, not explanations: student-teacher ratios range from 12.8 at Foster to 18.2 at Kennedy, and the 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible measure ranges from 51% at Brandeis to 93% at Maupin. Some school scores are suppressed, so comparisons reflect published results only.
Thank you for your feedback!