Summary:
Henderson County has 12 schools—8 elementary, 2 middle and 2 high—serving students from elementary through high school. In 2025–2026, elementary and middle schools averaged above state results in every reported subject, by about 5 to 11 points, but those averages conceal large differences between schools. The most important takeaway is how uneven results are: grade 5 math proficiency ranged from 27% at South Heights Elementary School to 81% at Spottsville Elementary School, a 54-point gap.
Spottsville Elementary School and Niagara Elementary School are the clearest elementary standouts, though their strengths differ: Spottsville leads in grade 3 math and reading and grade 5 math, reading, and editing and mechanics; Niagara leads in grade 4 math, reading, and science, as well as grade 5 writing and social studies. Both are above state results in all their reported tests. By contrast, South Heights is below the state in all its reported results, including grade 4 science at 18% versus 40% statewide and grade 5 writing at 13% versus 35%. Among middle schools, Henderson County South Middle School leads Henderson County North Middle School in most reported areas; its grade 8 writing result is 66%, compared with 38% at North. At high school, Henderson County High School is well ahead of The Central Academy in grade 10 math, 49% to 10%, and reading, 54% to 12%.
Changes over time are mixed, so no single trend describes every school. SchoolDigger’s average statewide ranking percentile across the 12 schools fell from 65th in 2023–2024 to 61st in 2025–2026; Jefferson Elementary rose 25 percentile points, while A B Chandler Elementary fell 44. Test results also diverged: Henderson County High’s grade 10 math fell from 65% to 49%, while South Middle’s grade 8 social studies rose from 34% to 55%. Other indicators offer context, not explanations: in 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 34% at Niagara and 79% at South Heights; Niagara’s student–teacher ratio was 18.2, compared with 14.0 at South Heights. Attendance is another difference: Niagara’s chronic absenteeism was 7% in 2025–2026, while Central Academy’s was 60%.
Thank you for your feedback!