Summary:
The two schools in Dexter serve prekindergarten through grade 12, with 291 students combined. In 2025–2026, both schools’ all-grades proficiency results were above state figures in ELA, mathematics, and science, but the strength of those results varies by school and subject. The clearest area-wide contrast is science: the schools’ results differ by 35 points.
Dexter Elementary has the strongest reported all-grades results: 79% in ELA, 63% in mathematics, and 76% in science, compared with 60%, 52%, and 41% at Dexter High. The elementary school’s results are higher by 18 points in ELA, 11 in mathematics, and 35 in science. Both are above state figures, though Dexter High’s science advantage is just 3 points, compared with 38 points at the elementary school. SchoolDigger ranks Dexter Elementary 44th of 657 schools, at the 93rd percentile with five stars; Dexter High ranks 116th of 340, at the 66th percentile with three stars. Grade-level results add important detail: Dexter High’s 7th-grade ELA is 87% versus 44% statewide, while its 10th-grade mathematics is 33% versus 37% statewide. Dexter Elementary’s 5th-grade mathematics is 81% versus 45% statewide.
Results are improving in some areas but not all. From 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, the two-school average rose 5 points in ELA and 6 in mathematics, but fell 4 in science; Dexter High’s science score dropped 9 points, while Dexter Elementary’s was essentially unchanged. SchoolDigger’s elementary percentile ranking stayed high across three years, moving from 92nd to 93rd, while the high school’s shifted from 53rd to 82nd and then 66th. Dexter Elementary has 134 students, a 12.8 student-teacher ratio, and a 53% free/reduced-lunch rate; Dexter High has 157 students, an 11.9 ratio, and a 41% rate. Dexter High also reports a 100% graduation rate, compared with 90% statewide, and chronic absenteeism of about 18%, matching the state figure. Because the schools serve different grades, their all-grades results are not like-for-like school comparisons.
Thank you for your feedback!