Summary:
Carbondale Education Service District 95 has one middle school serving grades 6–8: Carbondale Middle School, with 457 students. The most pressing concern is that, in 2025–26, chronic absenteeism was 45%, compared with 24% statewide, and achievement was also well below state results in every tested subject. The school’s all-grades ELA proficiency was 34% versus 56% statewide, a 23-point gap; math was 13% versus 40%, a 27-point gap; and eighth-grade science was 30% versus 52%, a 22-point gap. These substantial state gaps across all three subjects are the clearest finding for families.
There are no other middle schools in this list, so Carbondale Middle School is both the only possible top and bottom school, not a standout against local peers. Compared with the district, its ELA result was about 1 point higher, its math result was about 2 points lower, and its eighth-grade science result matched the district’s. SchoolDigger ranks the school 1,063rd of 1,126 Illinois middle schools, in the 6th percentile, with 0 stars; its listed ranking for Carbondale Education Service District 95 is 733rd of 738, in the 1st percentile, with 0 stars. These rankings are separate indicators from test scores.
Scores improved in ELA and science, but the school did not consistently close the state gap. From 2024–25 to 2025–26, ELA rose 5 points and its state gap narrowed by 2 points; science rose 6 points, but its gap widened by 1 point. Math edged up from 12.5% to 12.8%, while its state gap widened by 1 point. SchoolDigger’s percentile ranking fell from the 16th percentile in 2024–25 to the 6th in 2025–26 even as ELA improved. As context, the school’s student-teacher ratio was 12.9:1 in 2024–25, and 73% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible that year; these figures describe the school but do not explain its results. Because the list contains only one school, there is no local school-to-school comparison.
Thank you for your feedback!