Summary:
Shiloh, Illinois, has three listed public schools serving prekindergarten through grade 8: Wingate Elementary (PK–5, 424 students), Shiloh Elementary (PK–3, 245 students) and Shiloh Middle (grades 4–8, 331 students). Wingate is in Mascoutah CUD 19, while the other two schools are in Shiloh Village School District 85. In 2025–26, all three schools’ reported all-grades proficiency results were above state levels: their equal-school averages were 77% in ELA and 61% in math, compared with 56% and 40% statewide. The most important overall finding is that Wingate leads the area’s reported results in both subjects.
Wingate had the highest all-grades scores, at 85% in ELA and 74% in math—7 and 14 percentage points above the next-highest school in each subject. It also led Shiloh Middle in shared grades 4 and 5: by 4 points in grade 4 ELA and 25 in grade 4 math, and by 19 in grade 5 ELA and 15 in grade 5 math. The lowest result depends on the subject: Shiloh Elementary had the lowest all-grades ELA score (67%), while Shiloh Middle had the lowest math score (49%). Shiloh Middle’s ELA result (78%) was stronger than Shiloh Elementary’s (67%), but its math result was lower (49% versus 60%). These all-grades comparisons are not fully like-for-like because the schools serve different grades.
Scores generally rose from 2024–25 to 2025–26, with one exception: Shiloh Middle’s ELA increased by 9 percentage points, but its math slipped by 1; Wingate and Shiloh Elementary improved in both subjects. SchoolDigger ranks Wingate 111th of 1,737 schools, in the 94th percentile with five stars; it ranks Shiloh Middle 272nd of 1,126, in the 76th percentile with four stars. In 2024–25, free/reduced lunch eligible shares were 17% at Wingate, 28% at Shiloh Middle and 31% at Shiloh Elementary; student-teacher ratios were 11.6, 16.5 and 12.8, respectively. These are useful context, not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!