Summary:
Bethany, Illinois, has two schools: Okaw Valley Elementary School, serving pre-K through grade 4, and Okaw Valley High School, serving grades 9–12; together they enroll 332 students. Their different grade spans and results do not support a direct school-to-school test-score ranking. The most important finding is that results vary notably by grade and subject, rather than showing one school as a clear overall leader.
Okaw Valley Elementary stands out in grade-3 ELA: 48% of students were proficient, just above the state’s 47.7%, while grade-4 ELA was 48%, 8 points below the state. Across all grades, elementary ELA was 48%, 8 points below the state, and math was 29%, 11 points below; that math result was nevertheless 12 points above the district’s 17%. At Okaw Valley High, grade-9 ELA was the strongest reported result relative to the state, at 57% proficient and 4 points below. Grade-10 ELA was a weaker result: 35%, 18 points below the state. The other reported high-school results were also below state figures: grade-10 science by 16 points and grade-11 science by 7.
Elementary results improved against the state from 2024–25 to 2025–26: all-grades ELA rose 16 points and math rose 5, with their state gaps narrowing by 13 and 4 points, respectively. High-school trends were mixed: grade-9 ELA rose 25 points and its state gap narrowed by 26, while grade-10 ELA fell 11 points and its gap widened by 10. SchoolDigger ranked the elementary school at the 21st percentile in 2024–25 and the high school at the 29th percentile in 2025–26. The schools’ 2024–25 student-teacher ratios were similar, at 10.7 and 10.1; free/reduced lunch eligible figures that year were 55% and 52%, respectively. Chronic absenteeism in 2025–26 was 9% at the elementary school and 5% at the high school, compared with 24% statewide. These figures add context but do not explain score differences.
Thank you for your feedback!