Best Elementary Schools in Zip Code 83617

There are three elementary schools in zip code 83617—Shadow Butte Elementary School, Kenneth J Carberry Elementary, and Butte View School—serving grades PK-5 in the Emmett Independent District in Idaho, with about 1,057 students combined. All three serve a majority of economically disadvantaged families, with free/reduced lunch rates ranging from 54% at Shadow Butte to 64% at Butte View. The most complete performance data exists for Shadow Butte and Carberry, while Butte View has a shorter rank history and limited grade-level test breakdowns.

Kenneth J Carberry Elementary is the clear standout. It earned a 3-star rating in all three years of rank history and recently ranked in the 57th percentile statewide, far above its peers. Carberry exceeded state averages in both math and ELA and posted the highest science proficiency rate in the group (56% vs. 44% statewide). Shadow Butte Elementary sits in the middle: its two-star rating reflects modest performance, but it still beat the state average in math (46.2% vs. 43.1%) and matched the district average in ELA. Butte View School is the weakest performer, ranking in the 30th percentile in its only reported year and scoring well below district and state benchmarks—roughly 12 points below the state in math and 15.5 points below in ELA.

Perhaps the most interesting finding is that Carberry succeeds despite a slightly higher poverty rate than Shadow Butte, suggesting factors like instructional quality, school climate, or resources—Carberry spends about $1,600 more per student and has a lower student-teacher ratio—matter greatly. Chronic absenteeism tracks performance almost perfectly: Carberry has the lowest rate (10.2%), Shadow Butte falls in the middle (15.5%), and Butte View has the highest (21.7%, nearly double the state average). Butte View posted a strong science proficiency rate (50%) in 2024–25, well above district and state averages, but its low math and ELA scores and lack of recent rank data make it difficult to fully assess. For parents, Carberry is the district's strongest performer, Shadow Butte is a middle option with a recent upward trend, and Butte View faces significant challenges in attendance and academics.