Summary:
This analysis examines three elementary schools in zip code 34997 (Stuart, FL), all part of the Martin County School District, serving grades PK or K through 5, and reveals a clear performance divide between one standout school and two underperformers.
Crystal Lake Elementary School is the clear standout, ranking in the top 26% of Florida elementary schools (74th percentile) with a 4-star rating. It significantly outperforms its counterparts, with 72% of 3rd graders proficient in ELA and 86% in math, far exceeding district and state averages. Crystal Lake also boasts a lower chronic absenteeism rate (16.2%), a lower free/reduced lunch rate (38.83%), and a notably smaller student-teacher ratio (13.0) compared to the other schools. In contrast, Port Salerno Elementary School and Pinewood Elementary School both rank in the bottom 20% (1-star rating), with average ELA proficiency around 41-47% and math proficiency around 50-54%, well below district averages. Their chronic absenteeism rates (24.3% and 23.4%) are also significantly higher than Crystal Lake's.
Key takeaways include a strong correlation between socioeconomic factors and performance, as Crystal Lake has the lowest poverty rate and highest achievement. While Crystal Lake spends slightly more per student ($14,491), the spending difference is modest, suggesting factors like school leadership and community support are critical. The widening performance gap is evident in state rankings, with Crystal Lake remaining high while Port Salerno and Pinewood have declined from the 25th and 31st percentiles to the 19th percentile over recent years. For parents, this data highlights that Crystal Lake Elementary offers a distinctly higher-performing environment with smaller classes and better attendance, while the other two schools face significant challenges that may require targeted support.
Thank you for your feedback!