Summary:
Zip code 34243 in Sarasota, FL, is home to two elementary schools serving grades PK-5 within the Manatee school district: Marjorie G. Kinnan Elementary School and Florine J Abel Elementary School.
Marjorie G. Kinnan Elementary School stands out as the higher-performing school overall, with a state ranking in the 58th percentile compared to Florine J Abel Elementary School's 50th percentile. Kinnan has shown a strong upward trajectory, improving from the 41st percentile in just two years, while Abel has declined from the 59th percentile. Kinnan also boasts a lower chronic absenteeism rate (28.3%) that falls below both district and state averages, and it excels in English Language Arts, with 72% of 5th graders proficient versus Abel's 56%. However, Abel is a math powerhouse, with 76% of 5th graders proficient in math compared to Kinnan's 64%, and it spends slightly more per student ($14,983 vs. $14,629) with a marginally lower student-teacher ratio (14.2 vs. 14.9).
Despite Abel's resource advantages, Kinnan's higher overall ranking and lower absenteeism highlight that factors like school culture and instructional quality are critical. Both schools serve economically diverse populations, with free/reduced lunch rates of 68.01% at Kinnan and 73.61% at Abel. A notable data anomaly is that both schools report 100% proficiency in 6th-grade math, which is likely an error since they are K-5 schools. For parents, Kinnan offers stronger overall academics and engagement, while Abel provides exceptional math instruction and slightly more personalized attention.
Thank you for your feedback!