Summary:
This analysis examines eight elementary schools in zip code 34221 (Palmetto, FL), serving grades PK-5 or PK-8, within the Manatee School District, a 2-star district ranked 40th out of 70 in Florida.
The schools in this area present a starkly polarized educational landscape. Palmetto Charter School is the standout performer, a 5-star school ranking in the 93rd percentile statewide with a remarkably low 5% chronic absenteeism rate and 100% proficiency in Algebra 1 and Civics. In contrast, Blackburn Elementary School faces the greatest challenges, ranking in the 10th percentile with a 1-star rating and a 79.65% free/reduced lunch rate, the highest in the area. Virgil Mills Elementary School shows a strong positive trajectory as a 3-star school, improving its state ranking over three years and scoring above district averages in 5th-grade Science. Other schools like James Tillman Elementary Magnet School and Palm View K-8 School fall below average, while Hola! Elementary @ Msa and Palmetto Elementary School rank in the bottom third of the state.
Key metrics reveal a clear correlation between performance and socioeconomic factors. The average free/reduced lunch rate across all schools is 58%, but ranges from 29.04% at Hola! Elementary to 79.65% at Blackburn. Chronic absenteeism is a powerful predictor of success, with the top-performing Palmetto Charter at 5% and the lowest-performing Blackburn and James Tillman at 29.3% and 32.6%, respectively. Interestingly, the two highest-spending schools, Blackburn ($16,274 per student) and Palm View K-8 ($15,587), are the lowest-performing, suggesting that financial resources alone cannot overcome deep-rooted challenges. For several struggling schools, math scores are a relative strength, indicating potential effective math interventions.
Thank you for your feedback!