Summary:
Zip code 34112 in Naples, FL, is home to two public elementary schools, Shadowlawn Elementary School and Avalon Elementary School, both serving grades PK through 5 within the Collier County School District, which is ranked 13th out of 70 districts in Florida.
Shadowlawn Elementary School is the standout school in this area, showing a strong upward trajectory from a 2-star rating to a 3-star rating in the 68th percentile for the 2025-2026 school year. It outperforms Avalon Elementary School in nearly every subject, with a particularly dramatic gap in 4th-grade math where 88% of Shadowlawn students were proficient compared to just 50% at Avalon. Shadowlawn also benefits from a lower student-teacher ratio (13.3:1) and higher per-student spending ($19,577) compared to Avalon (15.9:1 and $17,876). In contrast, Avalon has remained stagnant with a 2-star rating in the low-to-mid 30th percentile for three years, and it shows a concerning "4th-grade slump" where scores drop significantly from 3rd grade in both ELA and math.
Both schools serve similar student populations, with nearly identical rates of economic disadvantage (around 59% free/reduced lunch) and chronic absenteeism (around 20%). This suggests that Shadowlawn's superior outcomes are likely driven by school-specific strategies and instructional practices rather than demographics alone. For parents, Shadowlawn Elementary School offers a rapidly improving environment with strong math performance and better resources, while Avalon Elementary School faces challenges with stagnant rankings and a notable drop in 4th-grade performance that may warrant closer investigation.
Thank you for your feedback!