Summary:
This analysis examines three elementary schools in zip code 33967 (Fort Myers, FL), serving grades Pre-K through 8, within the Lee school district, revealing a highly stratified educational landscape where one school dramatically outperforms its peers.
Three Oaks Elementary School is the clear standout, ranking in the 89th percentile statewide with a 4-star rating. It achieves exceptional test scores, such as 88% of 3rd graders proficient in ELA and 86% in Math, far exceeding district and state averages. This school also has the lowest chronic absenteeism rate (12.0%) and the lowest percentage of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch (24.97%). In stark contrast, San Carlos Park Elementary School spends the most per student ($13,124) but achieves only a 3-star rating and 54th percentile rank, with 50.31% of its students qualifying for free or reduced lunch. Athenian Academy Charter School presents a paradox: it has the lowest elementary scores in the zip code (e.g., 29% in 5th grade Science) yet achieves 100% proficiency in Geometry EOC, suggesting it excels at accelerating a few advanced math students while struggling with foundational education for most.
Key takeaways include that spending does not equal success, as Three Oaks outperforms San Carlos Park despite lower per-pupil funding. Chronic absenteeism is a clear warning sign, with the two lower-performing schools (San Carlos Park and Athenian Academy) having rates above 28%, more than double Three Oaks' rate. Athenian Academy, as a charter school, operates with a leaner model ($7,686 per student, 24.2:1 student-teacher ratio), which may contribute to its weak elementary performance despite its high school-level math success. Overall, Three Oaks Elementary is the top choice for consistent academic excellence, while families considering Athenian Academy should weigh its advanced math opportunities against its struggling core curriculum.
Thank you for your feedback!