Summary:
Zip code 33605 in Tampa is home to two middle schools, Orange Grove Middle Magnet School and Franklin Middle Magnet School, both part of the Hillsborough school district, serving grades 6-8 in a high-poverty area where over half of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Orange Grove Middle Magnet School stands out as the higher-performing school overall, earning a 2-star rating compared to Franklin's 1-star rating. Orange Grove consistently outperforms Franklin in core subjects like English Language Arts and Math, with a particularly strong ELA program where proficiency rates increase from 57% in 6th grade to 68% in 8th grade. However, Franklin Middle Magnet School has a remarkable outlier: a 100% proficiency rate in Geometry, far exceeding district and state averages. This success does not translate to other subjects, as Franklin generally underperforms, especially in 7th and 8th-grade Math where proficiency drops to 20% and 26% respectively. Both schools share a critical weakness in 7th-grade Math, with Orange Grove's proficiency plummeting to just 13%.
A key paradox emerges in resource allocation: Franklin spends 51% more per student ($16,155 vs. $10,679) and has a much lower student-teacher ratio (15.6:1 vs. 21.6:1) than Orange Grove, yet achieves lower overall academic results. This suggests that additional funding and smaller classes are not automatically translating into better outcomes. Both schools also face high chronic absenteeism rates above 33%, exceeding district and state averages, which is a significant barrier to learning. For parents, Orange Grove offers more consistent academic performance, while Franklin's Geometry program is exceptional but isolated, and both schools need to address systemic challenges in math instruction and attendance.
Thank you for your feedback!