Summary:
In zip code 33036 (Islamorada, FL), there is a single elementary school, Treasure Village Montessori Charter School, a public charter school serving grades PK through 8 with 179 students in the Monroe district.
Treasure Village Montessori Charter School shows a mixed academic profile. The school is a standout in English Language Arts (ELA), consistently outperforming both district and state averages across nearly all grade levels—for example, 5th-grade ELA proficiency reached 89% in the 2025-2026 school year. It also achieves perfect 100% proficiency in advanced courses like Algebra 1 and Civics EOC exams for two consecutive years. However, early elementary math is a significant weakness, with 3rd and 4th-grade math proficiency at just 42% in 2025-2026, far below state averages. The school’s state ranking has improved over time, reaching the 74th percentile (4 stars) in 2023-2024, though the most recent year shows a drop to the 55th percentile (3 stars). Per-student spending is notably high at $20,554, while chronic absenteeism sits at 25.1%, higher than the district average but lower than the state average.
Key takeaways for parents include the school’s exceptional ELA and advanced course performance, contrasted with early math challenges that may require additional support. The "middle school bounce" in math—where 6th-grade proficiency jumps to 77%—suggests the curriculum becomes more effective in upper grades. With only 179 students, the small environment allows for strong outcomes in some areas but can amplify struggles in others. The high per-student spending does not guarantee uniform excellence, raising questions about resource allocation for math and attendance issues. Overall, this school offers a specialized, high-performing option for families focused on ELA and advanced academics, but early math performance warrants attention.
Thank you for your feedback!