Summary:
In zip code 33012, Hialeah, Florida, two public middle schools—Henry H. Filer Middle School and Palm Springs Middle School—serve grades 6-8 within the Miami-Dade County Public School District, a 4-star district ranked in the 71st percentile in Florida.
These two schools present a striking contrast in resources and results. Henry H. Filer Middle School is a standout for efficiency: despite a higher poverty rate (71.86% free/reduced lunch), a larger student-teacher ratio (23.6:1), and half the per-student spending ($9,853) compared to its neighbor, it consistently outperforms Palm Springs Middle School in grade-level English Language Arts and Math proficiency across all three grades. Conversely, Palm Springs Middle School spends significantly more ($18,608 per student) and has a lower student-teacher ratio (13.9:1), yet it ranks lower statewide (12th percentile vs. Filer's 16th percentile) and struggles to match Filer's core academic results. Both schools share a dramatic split in performance: they excel in advanced End-of-Course exams (like Algebra 1 and Biology), often exceeding district averages, but the majority of their students fall below grade-level standards in FAST assessments for ELA and Math.
Key metrics show Henry H. Filer Middle School has 732 students and a 26.5% chronic absenteeism rate, while Palm Springs Middle School has 698 students and a higher 30.0% absenteeism rate. The data challenges the assumption that higher spending guarantees better outcomes, highlighting that school performance is driven by complex factors beyond funding. For parents, this means that Henry H. Filer Middle School may offer stronger core academic instruction despite fewer resources, while Palm Springs Middle School provides smaller class sizes and more spending per student, but with less consistent grade-level results.
Thank you for your feedback!