Summary:
In zip code 32778, located in Tavares, Florida, there are two elementary schools serving grades Pre-K through 8, both part of the Lake County school district, offering a stark contrast in academic performance and resource allocation.
Pinecrest Academy Tavares is the standout school in the area, consistently outperforming district and state averages across nearly every subject and grade level. It ranks in the top 20% of all Florida elementary schools with a 4-star rating, and its middle school performance is exceptionally strong, with 8th-grade ELA proficiency at 89% and 6th-grade math at 93%. In contrast, Tavares Elementary School is a struggling school, ranking in the bottom 15% of the state with a 1-star rating. The most striking finding is the inverse relationship between spending and performance: Tavares Elementary spends $11,111 per student—76% more than Pinecrest Academy's $6,310—yet achieves far lower academic results. For example, 3rd-grade ELA proficiency is 74% at Pinecrest Academy compared to just 32% at Tavares Elementary, and 5th-grade math proficiency is 68% versus 49%.
Chronic absenteeism is a key predictor of this performance gap. Tavares Elementary has a chronic absenteeism rate of 37.4%, nearly identical to the district average and significantly higher than the state average of 31.4%, while Pinecrest Academy's rate is just 21.3%. Additionally, Tavares Elementary has a higher percentage of students eligible for free/reduced lunch (58.39%) compared to Pinecrest Academy (43.52%), but this does not fully explain the massive performance gap, as many schools with similar poverty rates outperform Tavares Elementary. The ranking history shows diverging paths: Pinecrest Academy has been consistently high-performing, while Tavares Elementary has been on a downward trend, dropping from the 34th percentile in 2023-2024 to the 14th percentile in 2025-2026, indicating a deepening crisis rather than a one-year anomaly.
Thank you for your feedback!